14. old major declares: “and even the miserable lives we lead are not allowed to reach their natural span…

14. old major declares: “and even the miserable lives we lead are not allowed to reach their natural span. for myself i do not grumble, for i am one of the lucky ones. i am twelve years old and had over four hundred children. such is the natural life of a pig. but no animal escapes the cruel knife in the end.” which statement best explains the logical fallacy in this argument? a) it assumes that reproduction makes the pig’s life fulfilling. b) it relies too heavily upon facts and data to create a sense of urgency. c) it appeals to authority by referencing old major’s own age and thus, his wisdom. d) it uses a false cause fallacy by implying that death is only caused by humans.

14. old major declares: “and even the miserable lives we lead are not allowed to reach their natural span. for myself i do not grumble, for i am one of the lucky ones. i am twelve years old and had over four hundred children. such is the natural life of a pig. but no animal escapes the cruel knife in the end.” which statement best explains the logical fallacy in this argument? a) it assumes that reproduction makes the pig’s life fulfilling. b) it relies too heavily upon facts and data to create a sense of urgency. c) it appeals to authority by referencing old major’s own age and thus, his wisdom. d) it uses a false cause fallacy by implying that death is only caused by humans.

Answer

Brief Explanations:

El discurso de Old Major asume que la reproducción hace que la vida del cerdo sea satisfactoria, lo cual es una falacia lógica. No se presenta una conexión clara entre tener muchos hijos y tener una vida plena. Las otras opciones no representan la falacia lógica presente en el argumento.

Answer:

A. It assumes that reproduction makes the pig's life fulfilling.