decide if the following statement is valid or invalid. all residents of ohio are residents of the u.s. all…

decide if the following statement is valid or invalid. all residents of ohio are residents of the u.s. all residents of the u.s. live on planet earth. sue lives on planet earth so sue is a resident of ohio.

decide if the following statement is valid or invalid. all residents of ohio are residents of the u.s. all residents of the u.s. live on planet earth. sue lives on planet earth so sue is a resident of ohio.

Answer

Brief Explanations:

The first two statements establish a subset - superset relationship (Ohio residents are in U.S. residents, U.S. residents are on Earth). Just because Sue lives on Earth (a superset), we cannot conclude she is in Ohio (a subset). This is a logical fallacy of affirming the consequent.

Answer:

Invalid