mr. smith, who has been suffering from dementia for a long time, falls and breaks his hip. during his stay…

mr. smith, who has been suffering from dementia for a long time, falls and breaks his hip. during his stay in the hospital, mr. smiths 3 children spend hours visiting him and making sure he is receiving good care. however, when his children are not there, mr. smith repeatedly complains to his primary nurse, hank, that his children do not care about him at all. the day before mr. smith dies he rewrites his will. in the revised will mr. smith vehemently criticizes his children, deliberately leaves each of them only $1.00, and leaves the remainder of his sizable estate to the alzheimers association. hank promises mr. smith that he will deliver the revised will to his lawyer. hank knows it is likely that the court will nullify mr. smiths revised will because of his dementia. he also knows that the vehement criticism the revised will contains will also really upset his children. after mr. smith dies, hank must decide what to do about the revised will. since hank is an honorable, trustworthy person, he delivers mr. smiths revised will to his lawyer. which ethical theory best supports hanks decision?\nvirtue ethics\nutilitarianism\ndeontology\njust consequentialism

mr. smith, who has been suffering from dementia for a long time, falls and breaks his hip. during his stay in the hospital, mr. smiths 3 children spend hours visiting him and making sure he is receiving good care. however, when his children are not there, mr. smith repeatedly complains to his primary nurse, hank, that his children do not care about him at all. the day before mr. smith dies he rewrites his will. in the revised will mr. smith vehemently criticizes his children, deliberately leaves each of them only $1.00, and leaves the remainder of his sizable estate to the alzheimers association. hank promises mr. smith that he will deliver the revised will to his lawyer. hank knows it is likely that the court will nullify mr. smiths revised will because of his dementia. he also knows that the vehement criticism the revised will contains will also really upset his children. after mr. smith dies, hank must decide what to do about the revised will. since hank is an honorable, trustworthy person, he delivers mr. smiths revised will to his lawyer. which ethical theory best supports hanks decision?\nvirtue ethics\nutilitarianism\ndeontology\njust consequentialism

Answer

Brief Explanations:

Virtue Ethics emphasizes moral character. Hank is described as honorable and trustworthy. By delivering the will as promised, he is acting in line with his virtuous character traits, even though he anticipates negative consequences for the children and the likely nullification of the will. Utilitarianism focuses on maximizing overall well - being, which might not support his action as it could cause distress to the children. Deontology is about following rules and duties, but there is no clear rule - based obligation here that overrides concerns about the children's feelings. Just Consequentialism also focuses on consequences, and the negative consequences seem to outweigh the positive in this case.

Answer:

Virtue Ethics