page 326 13.1. what data and context are necessary to form a moral or ethical argument about pandemics? john…

page 326 13.1. what data and context are necessary to form a moral or ethical argument about pandemics? john is a young businessman whose job requires him to be in direct contact with the public during the covid - 19 pandemic. he always wears a mask and practices social distancing; however, he refuses to get vaccinated. he argues on the grounds that this interferes with his personal freedom. john still lives at home with his aging mother who is a diabetic as well as suffers from cancer. she has been vaccinated. john is her primary caregiver at home. it troubles his mother greatly that john will not get vaccinated. which of the following moral principles are in conflict in this case scenario? autonomy and justice respect for persons and utility justice and utility equity and happiness

page 326 13.1. what data and context are necessary to form a moral or ethical argument about pandemics? john is a young businessman whose job requires him to be in direct contact with the public during the covid - 19 pandemic. he always wears a mask and practices social distancing; however, he refuses to get vaccinated. he argues on the grounds that this interferes with his personal freedom. john still lives at home with his aging mother who is a diabetic as well as suffers from cancer. she has been vaccinated. john is her primary caregiver at home. it troubles his mother greatly that john will not get vaccinated. which of the following moral principles are in conflict in this case scenario? autonomy and justice respect for persons and utility justice and utility equity and happiness

Answer

Brief Explanations:

John values his personal freedom (autonomy) by refusing vaccination. However, as a caregiver to his vulnerable mother, there is a consideration of utility (the well - being and protection of his mother). Respect for persons involves respecting both John's autonomy and his mother's need for protection. Utility focuses on the overall good, which in this case could be protecting his mother from potential harm. So, respect for persons (including John's autonomy) and utility (his mother's well - being) are in conflict.

Answer:

respect for persons and utility