scenario 2 - emergency doctor (5 marks)\nyou are a specialist doctor scheduled for a rare heart transplant…

scenario 2 - emergency doctor (5 marks)\nyou are a specialist doctor scheduled for a rare heart transplant for a 32 - year - old patient. suddenly, you are notified of a severe accident involving a 72 - year - old man who needs immediate surgery to survive. you are the only specialist available.\nquestion: which patient do you choose to treat, and why? use the ethical frameworks you have learned.\nmarking breakdown:\n• ethical analysis using at least one framework: 2 marks\n• justification for your choice: 2 marks\n• reflection on moral character and integrity: 1 mark

scenario 2 - emergency doctor (5 marks)\nyou are a specialist doctor scheduled for a rare heart transplant for a 32 - year - old patient. suddenly, you are notified of a severe accident involving a 72 - year - old man who needs immediate surgery to survive. you are the only specialist available.\nquestion: which patient do you choose to treat, and why? use the ethical frameworks you have learned.\nmarking breakdown:\n• ethical analysis using at least one framework: 2 marks\n• justification for your choice: 2 marks\n• reflection on moral character and integrity: 1 mark

Answer

Brief Explanations:

Using utilitarianism (ethical framework), the 32 - year - old has more years of life potential. Saving them could lead to greater overall happiness (more years to contribute, family, etc.). Justification: maximizing utility (happiness/well - being) over a longer time span. Reflection on moral character: shows a focus on the greater good, a trait of integrity in making such a choice.

Answer:

Treat the 32 - year - old. Using utilitarianism (ethical framework), the 32 - year - old has more years of life ahead. Justification: maximizing overall well - being (more years to live, contribute). Reflection on moral character: shows integrity in choosing the greater good.