consider this claim:\nit would be better to have music on a desert island than books, since you can listen…

consider this claim:\nit would be better to have music on a desert island than books, since you can listen to music over and over again without getting bored.\nnow consider how someone might argue against this. which sentence presents the stronger and more reasonable counterclaim to the above claim?\nbooks often have vivid, interesting characters who could make you feel less lonely on the deserted island.\nbooks are more engrossing than music, so if you had one you wouldnt worry about having to build a fire or find food on the island.

consider this claim:\nit would be better to have music on a desert island than books, since you can listen to music over and over again without getting bored.\nnow consider how someone might argue against this. which sentence presents the stronger and more reasonable counterclaim to the above claim?\nbooks often have vivid, interesting characters who could make you feel less lonely on the deserted island.\nbooks are more engrossing than music, so if you had one you wouldnt worry about having to build a fire or find food on the island.

Answer

Brief Explanations:

The first counter - claim focuses on a valid emotional and human - connection aspect (books having characters to reduce loneliness) which is a reasonable point against the claim that music is better. The second counter - claim is not reasonable as it implies that having a book would make one ignore survival tasks (building a fire, finding food) which is an extreme and illogical assumption.

Answer:

Books often have vivid, interesting characters who could make you feel less lonely on the deserted island.