QUESTION IMAGE
Question
1 select all the distribution shapes for which it is most often appropriate to use the mean.
a bell - shaped
b bimodal
c skewed
d symmetric
e uniform
2 for which distribution shape is it usually appropriate to use the median when summarizing the data?
a bell - shaped
b skewed
c symmetric
d uniform
3 the number of writing instruments in some teachers’ desks is displayed in the dot plot.
dot plot with x - axis labeled number of writing instruments from 4 to 13, with dots at 5 (1), 6 (1), 7 (1), 8 (1), 9 (3), 10 (4), 11 (2), 12 (1)
which is greater, the mean or the median?
explain your reasoning, using the shape of the distribution.
Question 1
The mean is most appropriate for symmetric distributions (including bell - shaped, symmetric, and uniform as bell - shaped is a type of symmetric, and uniform is also symmetric in a sense). Bimodal and skewed distributions are better summarized with median as mean is affected by outliers or multiple modes. So bell - shaped (A), symmetric (D), and uniform (E) are correct.
Skewed distributions have outliers that affect the mean. The median is resistant to outliers, so for skewed (B) distributions, median is usually appropriate. Bell - shaped, symmetric, and uniform distributions are better summarized with mean.
Step 1: Analyze the distribution shape
First, we count the number of dots (frequency) for each value:
- 5: 1 dot
- 6: 1 dot
- 7: 1 dot
- 8: 1 dot
- 9: 3 dots
- 10: 4 dots
- 11: 2 dots
- 12: 1 dot
The distribution is symmetric (the left and right sides of the peak at 10 are relatively balanced). For a symmetric distribution, the mean and median are approximately equal? Wait, no, let's calculate mean and median.
Step 2: Calculate the median
First, find the total number of data points. Sum the frequencies: \(1 + 1+1 + 1+3 + 4+2 + 1=14\). Since \(n = 14\) (even), the median is the average of the \(\frac{n}{2}=7\)th and \(\frac{n}{2}+ 1 = 8\)th values.
Let's list the data in order: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 9, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 11, 11, 12.
The 7th value is 9 and the 8th value is 10. So median \(=\frac{9 + 10}{2}=9.5\).
Step 3: Calculate the mean
Mean \(=\frac{\sum_{i = 1}^{n}x_{i}f_{i}}{n}\), where \(x_{i}\) is the value and \(f_{i}\) is the frequency.
\[
\]
Mean \(=\frac{127}{14}\approx9.07\)? Wait, no, I must have miscalculated. Wait, 51 = 5, 61=6 (total 11), 71 = 7 (18), 81=8 (26), 93 = 27 (53), 104=40 (93), 112 = 22 (115), 121=12 (127). \(n = 1 + 1+1+1 + 3+4+2+1=14\). So mean \(=\frac{127}{14}\approx9.07\)? But median is 9.5. Wait, maybe my frequency count is wrong. Let's re - count the dots:
Looking at the dot plot:
- 5: 1 dot
- 6: 1 dot
- 7: 1 dot
- 8: 1 dot
- 9: 3 dots (so 3)
- 10: 4 dots (so 4)
- 11: 2 dots (so 2)
- 12: 1 dot (so 1)
Total: 1+1+1+1 + 3+4+2+1=14. Correct.
Wait, maybe the distribution is symmetric? Wait, the left side (5,6,7,8) has 4 data points, the right side (11,12) has 3 data points, and the middle (9,10) has 7 data points. Wait, maybe it's approximately symmetric. Wait, but when I calculated mean is approximately 9.07 and median is 9.5? That can't be. Wait, no, I think I made a mistake in the order of the data.
Wait, the data points are: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 9, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 11, 11, 12. Let's list them in order:
Position 1: 5
Position 2: 6
Position 3: 7
Position 4: 8
Position 5: 9
Position 6: 9
Position 7: 9
Position 8: 10
Position 9: 10
Position 10: 10
Position 11: 10
Position 12: 11
Position 13: 11
Position 14: 12
Ah! I made a mistake in the 7th and 8th positions. The 7th position is 9, the 8th position is 10. So median is \(\frac{9 + 10}{2}=9.5\).
Now calculate the mean again:
\[
\]
Mean \(=\frac{127}{14}\approx9.07\)? Wait, that's less than median. But the distribution looks symmetric? Wait, no, maybe the dot plot is symmetric around 9.5? Wait, 5 and 12: 5 + 12 = 17, 6 and 11: 6+11 = 17, 7 and 10: 7 + 10=17, 8 and 9: 8 + 9 = 17. Oh! So it is symmetric. Then why is the mean less than median? Wait, no, my calculation of the mean must be wrong.
Wait, 51 = 5, 61=6 (total 11), 71 = 7 (18), 81=8 (26), 93 = 27 (53), 104=40 (93), 112 = 22 (115), 121=12 (127). 127 divided by 14: 14*9 = 126, so 127/14=9 + 1/14≈9.07. But median is 9.5. Wait, this is a contradiction. Wait, no, the number of data points: let's count the dots again.
Looking at the dot plot:
- 5: 1 dot
- 6: 1 dot
- 7: 1 dot
- 8…
Snap & solve any problem in the app
Get step-by-step solutions on Sovi AI
Photo-based solutions with guided steps
Explore more problems and detailed explanations
A. bell - shaped, D. symmetric, E. uniform