QUESTION IMAGE
Question
private schools are better schools than public schools because they get better students and have better teachers.
what type of fallacy is shown here?
either... or analogy- there are only two choices presented - private or public school.
circular reasoning- the first premise merely restates the second about school grades.
false analogy-- public schools must accept all students and still have high state standards.
Brief Explanations
- For the first option: The argument isn't about presenting only two choices (private or public) as the only options, so "Either... or analogy" is incorrect.
- For the second option: Circular reasoning occurs when the conclusion (private schools are better) is restated in the premises (better students, better teachers imply they are better schools). This matches the argument.
- For the third option: A false analogy would involve an inappropriate comparison, but here the issue is restating the conclusion, not a flawed analogy.
Snap & solve any problem in the app
Get step-by-step solutions on Sovi AI
Photo-based solutions with guided steps
Explore more problems and detailed explanations
B. Circular Reasoning- The first premise merely restates the second about school grades.