Question

question 8 of 10
counterclaim: students sometimes need to be able to use their phones, especially in an emergency situation.
which claim best corresponds to this counterclaim?
a. the use of cell phones should be banned in schools.
b. schools should provide students with cell phones.
c. cell phones can be useful learning tools in the classroom.
d. cell phones are too expensive and should be cheaper.

Explanation:

A counterclaim argues against an original claim. The given counterclaim states students need phone access for emergencies, which directly opposes a total ban on school cell phones. The other options do not conflict with this counterclaim: B is about providing phones, C focuses on learning uses, D addresses cost, none of which the counterclaim pushes back against.

Answer:

A. The use of cell phones should be banned in schools.