Question

task #3
recruitment brochure: sparta and athens are in a struggle to become the most powerful city - state in greece.
your final task will be to construct an appealing, informative recruitment brochure to lure all other greeks to
organize under either an athenian or spartan model of rule. choose which model you think is better and use
the pros from task #2 (as well as the cons from the opposing model) to create your brochure. a quality
brochure will include:

• an engaging and appealing title page
• pros and cons throughout the brochure which favor one model and contest the other
• photos or illustrations to supplement your material
• a one page written explanation of why military strength is better than educational development (sparta),

or educational development is better than military strength (athens).

Explanation:

To create the recruitment brochure, first choose between Athenian (emphasizes education, democracy) or Spartan (emphasizes military strength, discipline) models. For example, if choosing Athens:

1. Title Page: "Join Athens - Where Minds and Democracy Flourish!" with an illustration of the Parthenon and citizens debating.
2. Pros of Athens: Highlight democratic participation (all male citizens can vote), cultural achievements (philosophy, art, theater), educational opportunities (schools for boys to learn reading, writing, rhetoric).
3. Cons of Sparta: Note the harsh military training (boys taken from families at 7, strict discipline with little personal freedom), oligarchic rule (only a few elites hold power), and lack of cultural development (focused solely on war).
4. Written Explanation (Athens): Explain that educational development fosters critical thinking, innovation, and a just society. A well - educated citizenry can solve problems through debate (like in the Assembly) rather than force. Military strength (like Sparta's) is short - lived; a society built on education and democracy creates lasting progress (e.g., Athens' contributions to philosophy, science, and government systems that influenced the modern world).

If choosing Sparta:

1. Title Page: "Sparta - The Shield of Greece, Where Strength Unites Us!" with an illustration of Spartan warriors in formation.
2. Pros of Sparta: Emphasize military prowess (trained from childhood to be fearless warriors, making Sparta the strongest military force in Greece), social unity (everyone works for the state: men fight, women bear strong children, helots farm), and stability (strict laws and discipline prevent internal unrest).
3. Cons of Athens: Note the democratic flaws (only male citizens can vote, slaves and women excluded), political infighting (e.g., the Peloponnesian War was partly due to Athenian ambition), and over - reliance on naval power which was vulnerable (unlike Sparta's land - based, well - trained army).
4. Written Explanation (Sparta): Argue that military strength is the foundation of survival in a world of city - state rivalries. Sparta's military training ensures Greece is protected from enemies (like Persia). A society with a strong military can enforce order (unlike Athens' sometimes chaotic democracy) and secure resources. Educational development (Athens') is a luxury when enemies threaten; military strength is a necessity.

Answer:

The process to create the recruitment brochure involves choosing a model (Athenian or Spartan), then developing the title page, pros/cons, illustrations, and written explanation as outlined above. For example, a sample brochure for Athens would highlight democracy, education, and cultural achievements while critiquing Sparta's harshness and lack of freedom. A sample for Sparta would highlight military strength, unity, and stability while critiquing Athens' democratic flaws and over - ambition.